Chicago's past is marred by tragedy and pain, with natural disasters, horrific accidents, and bloody mass slayings leaving an indelible mark on its culture. This dark history has given rise to terrifying urban legends and ghost stories, making Chicago's ghost stories some of the creepiest in the US. The city's haunted legacy is a testament to its turbulent past. Here, we'll explore some of Chicago's most haunted places and the ghosts you'd rather avoid.
About this list
- 1

Mt. Carmel cemetery holds Al Capone and other famous gangsters, but the burial ground is better known forAnother famous resident.The mysterious Italian Bride.
Julia Buccola-Petta was her real name. She died young in 1921 during childbirth. After burial, her mother began having strange dreams. Julia would tell her she was alive and needed help. After six years of these dreams, her mother finally had the body dug up. Opening the casket shocked everyone. Julia's body had not decayed at all since burial. No one offers an explanation. Many people report seeing a ghostly woman in white haunting Julia's grave.
1,710 - 2

One of theworst airline disasters.Flight 191 happened in Chicago, 1979. The plane dropped from O'Hare International after takeoff. Flight 191 took the lives of all 271 passengers and crew. Investigators blamed a stress crack in a flange holding the engine pylon. That day changed the entire community.
Soon after,reports beganof ghostly activity near the crash site emerged. People claimed seeing odd, bobbing white lights, but no source appeared.The creepiest stories.came from a mobile home park next to the site. For months after the crash, residents reported frantic knocking at their doors. No one was ever there. Today, strange knocks, odd sounds, and a few spirits roaming the area still happen.
1,395 - 3

Resurrection Mary is one of Chicago'smost famousghost stories. A young woman wanders Resurrection Catholic Cemetery streets. She scares good Samaritans who stop to help her go home.
A popular legend says she was a young woman in the early 1930s who loved dancing. She went to dance halls for fun. One night, a car hit her on the way home. She was then buried in the cemetery in her dancing clothes.
Now, her spirit moves around the cemetery and the dance halls. Mary still goes to dance halls. She finds a boy to dance with. She asks him for a ride home. She tells her date she lives on the cemetery grounds because her father is the caretaker. As they reach the cemetery, she vanishes right in front of his eyes.
1,166 - 4

The Great Fire of 1871 remains one of Chicago's worst events. It killed 300 people. Over 100,000 lost their homes. The water tower miraculously stayed standing among the destruction, thanks mostly tothe workof one brave worker.
A man stayed behind as the fire raced toward the tower, manning the pumps instead of fleeing. He took his life to avoid burning alive just before the fire consumed him. Now, his ghost haunts the water tower he tried to protect. Tourists and locals see a shadowy figure of a dangling man from the tower's upstairs windows.
908 - 5

The Eastland steamer capsizing in Chicago remains one of the worst boating disasters. The gigantic ship headed for Michigan City. A horrible event caused the boat to tip over. Nearly 850 people aboard died out of an estimated 2,500. No one ever solved why the boat tipped.The story was far from over.The Eastland Disaster appears in the list 'Creepiest Ghost Stories From Chicago'.
Oprah Winfrey took over the armory building where many people died in the disaster. Crew members claimed the passengers' ghosts haunted the building. They heard strange noises, like children laughing and glasses clinking, and saw apparitions. One apparition became known as the Gray Lady.Gray Lady.The site of the disaster is supposedly haunted. People passing the spot report hearing the bloodcurdling screams of the doomed passengers.
736 - 6

The mysterious disappearance of sisters Patricia and Barbara Grimes in 1956 shook Chicago. The massive search to find these girls took wild turns. The search ended with their bodies found in the woods. Finding out who killed them cost the public and police a lot. Police questioned thousands but never found the needed evidence.The search took wild turns., but their bodies were found in the woods. The search to find out who slew them took a massive toll on the public and the police, and their cases remain unsolved.
Sadly, the girls' bodies were dumped at a ravine's edge, just feet from the road. A small house sat among the trees near where they were found. The family living there left the house suddenly. Later, vandals burned the house down. Some think the family left because it was haunted.The Grimes sisters were haunted.Ghosts of the Grimes sisters haunt the house. Reports of strange happenings from people exploring the area confirm this theory.
573 - 7

America is built on bloody fights and skirmishes. The Fort Dearborn Massacre remains a major event.The Fort Dearborn Massacre was one of the bloodiest.The War of 1812 increased tension between settlers and Native Americans. Fort Dearborn was a stronghold. Captain Nathan Heald was told to leave everything to the Native Americans. Heald did not act fast enough. Potawatomi Indians surrounded the fort. After tense talks and broken promises, a bloody fight killed over 50 people.
Carnage sparked ghostly tales. People said the fort site haunted. Reports quieted after the fort fell and Chicago grew over it. In the early 1980s, construction happened. Human remains were found, dated to the event. Weeks later, people saw semi-transparent figures in pioneer and military clothes. Most looked terrified or screamed silently.
538 - 8

Anyone who took a history class has heard of the The St. Valentine's Day Massacre appeared in 'Creepiest Ghost Stories From Chicago'.This bloody attack ended Al Capone's power. It also started his fall, convincing the public he needed stopping. Seven people died in a brutal execution on Clark Street. Their spirits supposedly haunt the spot today.
People claim to hear screams and machine-gun fire near the mass slaying site. They feel intense fear there. Pets also react, barking or whining when they pass.
466 - 9

Bachelor's Grove Cemetery is one of Chicago's most haunted cemeteries. Over 100 documented paranormal reports exist. No new burials happen there for years, yet it remains a well-known haunted spot in the Windy City.
No one knows what caused the hauntings. Most people think two things. Either teenagers in the '60s arrived, trashed the whole cemetery, and woke the spirits. Or, reports of chicken and small animal remains near the area point to occult actions.
Visitors often report phantom cars appearing and vanishing randomly. Some claim to see a farmer apparition wandering. This farmer died in the 1870s after getting caught in his horse's reins and dragged into a pond.
407 - 10

In the 1870s, Adolph Luetgert, a successful German meat packer, moved to Chicago. He opened a sausage factory that became a huge success, making him rich. He married Louisa Bicknese, but their marriage faced constant arguments and fights. One dayLouisa vanished. Police investigation later showed Luetgert killed Bicknese. He hid her body by boiling her in acid and burning her. They checked the factory boiler and found human remains plus two of Louisa's rings. Luetgert went to jail, but his wife's spirit was unhappy seeing him locked up.
Luetgert claimed his wife haunted him after he was imprisoned, driving him insane. He died in 1900, still claiming innocence. People began seeing her ghost at her old house and the sausage factory. Now, the house and factory are gone; people see her only on the anniversary of her death in May.
386 - 11

Robert Givens built a castle in 1886 in Chicago, mimicking the estates of his home country, Ireland. Various groups owned it over time; the Beverly Unitarian Church runs it now. A ghost of a young girl, left over from when the castle served as a boarding school, haunts the grounds.
The girlreportedlyshe perished in the early 1930s from influenza. One early encounter with her spirit occurred in the 1960s, when athe custodiansaw the girl, spoke with her, then was shocked when she vanished completely. Reports continue of her spirit roaming, along with odd flickering lights and strange sounds.
370 - 12

Alexander RobinsonAlexander Robinson became an early leader in Chicago. His mother was an Ottawa Indian; his father was a Scottish trader. His mixed background earned him respect from Native Americans and early settlers. He worked to connect the two groups and grow Chicago into a larger city.
After he died, his family members took his land in the woods near Lawrence Avenue. They held wild parties and lived a slightly hedonistic life. Suspicion fell on the area after three disrobed bodies were found bound in a ditch near their land, but those cases went unsolved for years.
A large stone stands as a monument to the Robinson family and their achievements, butreportsseem to suggest their spirits do not rest peacefully. Strange events, like spirits resembling Native Americans and frightening tribal drum sounds, are often reported near the burial site.
274 - 13

The Hull House in Chicago began with good intentions. It aimed to be a hope center, a community house to educate and aid new European immigrants in the late 1800s. Its legacy soon wasovershadowedby something much worse, as the Hull House was thought to house the Devil Baby.
The legend states a baby was born to adevout Catholic and her husband, who was completely atheist.They said the baby had pointed ears, horns, and a tail. The couple could do nothing about it, so they locked the baby in the attic at the Hull House. The story spread fast. Soon, the Hull House turned away crowds wanting to see the Devil Baby. People knocked on the door hoping for a glimpse. Though the legend isn't believed as much now, many still believe a deformed child was in the attic. Sometimes, at night, a deformed face appears looking out the attic window.
254
More like this

US' Most Famous Unsolved Murders
The US's most famous unsolved murders are featured in this list. Many cases remain open, while others are closed. Several suspects were named in some cases, but none were charged due to insufficient evidence.

Famous Unsolved Murders
History's most vicious murders are on this list, with many remaining unsolved. Famous cases include those where suspects were charged, but acquitted due to lack of evidence.

Famous Unsolved Murders of Families
Murders where the killer is never found are terrifying. When entire families are murdered, the crime becomes even more horrifying. This list explores the most famous unsolved murders of families and couples.

17 People Share Funny Stories Of Being Mistaken For Employees
On Subreddit r/IDontWorkHereLady, people share funny stories of being mistaken for employees. We've compiled the most hilariously frustrating ones, varying from frustrating to wholesome - vote up the best ones!

Comments (0)
Join the conversation
Sign in to share your take and reply to others.
First take? Share what stood out to you.