Skip to main content

Iconic Roles That Nobody Else Should Ever Play

By Every Day Story20 items
Share
🔥 2.3K votes

About this list

Reese Witherspoon as Elle Woods and Tom Hanks as Forrest Gump are perfect casts. It's hard to imagine Danny DeVito not playing Louie De Palma or Alec Baldwin not playing Jack Donaghy. Some movie and TV roles are so iconic that only one person can play them. While many actors have been Batman or Superman, Robert Downey Jr. is the only Iron Man. Which performances are so iconic that no other actor should play them? Vote for the most iconic roles.

Crowd-ranked
Anything
updating live20 items
  • 1
    Forrest Gump - 'Forrest Gump'

    Tom Hanks won his second straight Oscar for playing Forrest Gump. John Travolta and Bill Murray were rumored actors for the role. Still, Hanks made the movie what it is.

    A simple man with limited mental skills became a war hero, millionaire, ping-pong champion, and shrimping boat captain. This story might make audiences shrug. It is an outrageous, unbelievable tale. Hanks gave Forrest his everyman quality. We believe the story because we believe in Hanks.Forrest GumpHe could have possibly succeeded.

  • 2
    Iron Man/Tony Stark - 'Iron Man'

    No actor will ever link to the Marvel Cinematic Universe like Robert Downey Jr.Iron ManIron Man launched the MCU. It made superhero movies the biggest blockbusters of the 21st century. Downey is as impressive as Iron Man and Tony Stark, the master inventor.

    Before his Marvel casting, Downey had a rough past with jail time and substance use. His on-screen alter ego, Tony Stark, is a flawed man. His flaws make him relatable. He is a genius billionaire who wants to save the world. Other actors played Batman and Superman. No other actor can play Iron Man.

  • 3
    Tyrion Lannister - 'Game of Thrones'

    Tyrion Lannister is wittier, smarter, and more honest than anyone in Westeros.Game of ThronesThe character could seem unsympathetic or pathetic. His family disrespected him, and no one gave him credit. He had to earn it. Peter Dinklage made Tyrion the most liked and interesting character on the series.

    Tyrion is flawed. He is a drunken womanizer with little ambition when we first see him in the HBO series. Dinklage made the audience believe Tyrion changed from a spoiled Lannister to a queen's ally and war strategy expert.Game of ThronesA fan might see another actor as Jon Snow (Kit Harington) or Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clarke), but no one replaces Dinklage as Tyrion.

  • 4
    John McClane - 'Die Hard'

    Bruce Willis played Detective John McClane in fiveDie HardWillis plays Detective John McClane in five movies. He appeals because his everyman quality makes saving the Nakatomi Plaza from Hans Gruber (Alan Rickman) seem fun. If he had fitting shoes, things would have gone smoother.

    Willis may not look like a typical action hero, especially compared to other80s action starsJohn McClane suits 80s action stars like Arnold Schwarzenegger and Sylvester Stallone. Opponents underestimate his street smarts and refusal to quit, which makes him perfect for the role.

    Anything
    🔥 238 up · 46 down▼ 1 below editor

    Also ranks #1 on 17 Roles Where TV Stars Became Movie Stars · #1 on Best Bruce Willis Characters · #1 on Die Hard Characters

  • 5
    Ellen Ripley - 'Alien'

    Sigourney Weaver played Ellen Ripley in four movies.Ellen Ripley is an Alien.Audiences never saw a heroine like Ripley in modern cinema during the first film in 1979. Ripley was brilliant, brave, and outsmarted a crafty Xenomorph while her crew failed.

    Weaver's role as Lieutenant Ripley changed female characters on film. Considering another actress playing Ripley seems impossible. Weaver played other parts in other movies, but the science-fiction icon remains her best role.

  • 6
    Jules Winnfield - 'Pulp Fiction'

    Quentin Tarantino's 1994 non-linear masterpiece is so iconic. Few actors can play any role in that movie. Samuel L. Jackson is the only one who can play gangster Jules Winnfield.

    Winnfield finds a moment of calm during the diner scene. He and Vincent Vega (John Travolta) face gunfire. They avoid being hit by luck or maybe divine help. Jackson shows Jules's ruthless side. Being a Tarantino movie, he looks cool doing it.

  • 7
    Jack Torrance - 'The Shining'

    Steven Weber and Henry Thomas both played Jack Torrance as the antagonist in different versions ofJack Torrance is in The Shining.Neither Weber nor Thomas reached Jack Nicholson's iconic levels in Stanley Kubrick's vision of Stephen King's horror tale.

    Nicholson played Torrance in the original version ofJack Torrance is in The Shining.In 1980, Torrance struggles with slow, building insanity inside the Overlook Hotel. He and his family are trapped in the snowy mountain hideaway during winter. Tension builds, threatening Jack's sanity. After months of cabin fever and the Overlook ghosts pushing him, Jack explodes, trying to kill his wife and son.

    Nicholson's insanity and rage fit the role perfectly. Watching him stalk the hotel halls after losing his mind proves only Nicholson captures Torrance's delusion and destruction.

  • 8
    Elle Woods - 'Legally Blonde'

    Reese Witherspoon took a cliché 'dumb blonde' stereotype. She became a Harvard Law student and an accomplished lawyer inElle Woods is in Legally Blonde.Elle Woods is in and.Elle Woods is in Legally Blonde 2..Elle Woods is in Legally Blonde 3.is set for the big screen in 2020. Witherspoon plays a character who can carry a whole franchise. She achieves this with charisma and grace.

    Initially, Elle Woods seems innocent and clueless. She is a charming sorority girl no one takes seriously. Witherspoon's unique relatability, quick comebacks, and polished comedy show her change into a character with strength and integrity.

  • 10
    Tony Soprano - 'The Sopranos'

    Tony Soprano is in The Sopranos.The TV series that started the modern Golden Age of Television often gets credit for this. This era featured a protagonist who acted as a ruthless, violent mob leader.The SopranosJames Gandolfini started as an unknown actor. Over six brilliant seasons of the show, he became the face of the crime boss. Fans saw Gandolfini and Tony Soprano as one.

    Gandolfini used his skill to transform into a man people thought could cry over ducks in his pool. Then, five minutes later, he started a violent fit, capable of ending a life with just his bare hands. Many say Gandolfini was sweet and caring. The actor went deep into the rage of Soprano, affecting his personal life and health. Still, he made one of the small screen's true legends.affectedhis personal life and health. Still, he created one of the true legends of the small screen.

  • 11
    Patrick Bateman - 'American Psycho'

    Christian Bale took the role of Patrick Bateman in the 2001 cult hit.American PsychoIn the film, Bateman fixates on his appearance and his social standing. He is also possibly a serial killer with an addiction to pop music and chainsaws.

    Bale played Bateman with one winking eye toward camp and the other toward killing. He would later become the Dark Knight. The Oscar-winning actor is the only one who walked Bateman's fine line between satire and horror.

    An attempt was made to recast Bateman in the direct-to-video sequel.American Psycho II: All-American GirlCritics and fans dismissed this sequel as a mess, giving it a low 11% on Rotten Tomatoes.Rotten Tomatoes)

  • 12
    Louie De Palma - 'Taxi'

    Louie De Palma could have been an unpleasant character with his bullying and crude selfish actions. However, Danny DeVito somehow made the TV audience love the taxi dispatcher.TV GuidenamedDe Palma the No. 1TV character of all time, ahead of Ed Norton (Art Carney) and Lucille Ball's Lucy Ricardo.

    DeVito delivered De Palma's insults with a sharp edge of cruelty. He was miserable and demeaning despite his short height. A different actor playing De Palma would be blasphemous.

  • 13
    Ash Williams - 'Evil Dead'

    Ash is an important character in Sam Raimi'sEvil Deadfranchise that Ash is the only character to appear in all theEvil Deadmovies, the television seriesAsh vs Evil Dead, and all the many different versions of theEvil Deadvideo game. Bruce Campbell is Ash; Ash is Bruce Campbell.

    Campbell is a different kind of horror hero. His many flaws make him human. When we first meet Ash, he is not the smartest or the bravest. Yet, he learns how to survive and becomes the champion fans deserve.Evil Deadfans deserve.

    Empire rankedAsh the No. 1horror movie characterever, above Hannibal Lecter and Freddy Krueger. Campbell spoke about feeling at the top of the list and how his character changed over time:

    I feel great. Your readers are smart, discerning people with good taste. We like the Ash character because he evolves; he is a flawed character.Evil DeadAsh becomes a worthless git who slowly learns to survive. The second version gives him more abilities; he acts like a Vietnam veteran. By the third version, he is a full, ugly American who causes hundreds of innocent deaths through his ignorance. This makes for a great lead character. Hollywood would not allow that character, which is why I love those movies. Audiences enjoy it. Some people find Ash endearing because he does not know what he is doing!

  • 14
    Marge Gunderson - 'Fargo'

    The Coen brothers subvert genre codes. They turned traditional film noir on its head in their 1996 crime film.FargoThe postmodern filmmakers move the story away from noir's dark, sweaty city. They set the movie in the Midwest during winter. The brothers also took the typical male noir anti-hero with a dark past and flipped the script by creating the likable, very pregnant Chief Marge Gunderson.

    Frances McDormand plays Gunderson investigating a triple homicide with Minnesota charm. Everyone underestimates the police chief, but she solves the crime and finds the culprits. McDormand earned an Academy Award for Best Actress for playing Gunderson and has an active film career. Her role as the reasonable, honest, intelligent Marge remains her most recognizable.

  • 15
    Alex DeLarge - 'A Clockwork Orange'

    British actor Malcolm McDowell played the leader of the antisocial delinquent group of droogs in Stanley Kubrick's 1971 adaptation.A Clockwork OrangeAlex is a violent, insane, yet charming young man on screen. He beats up innocent people for fun. McDowell captured Alex's sinister and deranged behavior with acting that was both exaggerated and believable.

    The movie tries to rehabilitate Alex through psychological conditioning. McDowell makes viewers sympathize with Alex by playing the character as vulnerable, despite the horrible crimes he commits and his total lack of remorse. McDowell showed a duality in the character that only he could capture.

  • 16
    Leslie Knope - 'Parks and Recreation'

    Amy Poehler played Leslie Knope onParks and RecreationAmy Poehler played Leslie Knope to perfection for seven seasons. Knope is the deputy director of parks and recreation in Pawnee, Indiana. She is smart, ambitious, and simply wants to make the people of Pawnee happy. Poehler uses her sharp comedy skills best when Knope often goes too far.

    Poehler owns Leslie Knope. She plays Knope as the ever-hopeful optimist across multiple seasons. Poehler immediately brings Knope to mind. She played the role fully and made an icon.

  • 17
    Bill 'The Butcher' Cutting - 'Gangs of New York'

    The character is Bill the Butcher from Martin Scorsese's epic.The show is Gangs of New York.Bill the Butcher is based on the 19th-century real-life gang leader Bill Poole. Daniel Day-Lewis took the role of the violent villain after a five-year break from acting.Day-Lewis took a five-year break from acting.Scorsese convinced Day-Lewis to play Bill. The method actor then created one of modern cinema's most ruthless screen characters.

    To get the Butcher role, Lewis worked in a real butcher shop for weeks. He even learned how to gut a carcass. In a rare interview, the thespian discussed this.Day-Lewis described his process.Bill 'The Butcher' Cutting: Lewis earned another Academy Award nomination. No one else can play Bill the Butcher again. Lewis is one of the best actors of his generation because he becomes the character, lives and breathes his essence, or he does nothing.

    You must learn these things well enough to act like you've known them forever. This is not a blind search; you have clues. It is like picking items off shelves. Or like people who grab everything in a supermarket when they win a game show. But I do it differently; eventually, you discard the trash and distill the character down to its core.

    The hard work and effort earned Lewis another Academy Award nomination. No one else can play Bill the Butcher again. Lewis is one of the best actors of his generation because he becomes the character, lives and breathes his essence, or he doesn't work at all.

  • 18
    Omar Little - 'The Wire'

    Michael K. Williams played Omar Little, a criminal with moral integrity, on The Wire.Omar Little appeared on The Wire for five seasons.Omar was Baltimore's criminal Robin Hood. He only robbed dealers. Enemies both feared and respected Omar.

    Omar was a walking paradox. He was tough outside but soft inside. Williams showed this duality convincingly. Omar became one of the most popular characters on the HBO series with well-written people.

  • 19
    Annie Hall - 'Annie Hall'

    Sometimes a character moves from the screen to popular culture icon status. The main character from Woody Allen's 1977 comedy Annie Hall.Annie Hall.Annie Hall became a fashion statement and a feminist role model for the era.

    Keaton and Allen dated for five years. The director denies Annie is based on Keaton. However, the actress thinks...the actress believesthat their similarities, like insecurity and the desire to sing, are too obvious to ignore. Diane Keaton is Annie Hall, so no one else could play Annie Hall.

  • 20
    Jack Donaghy - '30 Rock'

    Alec Baldwin built a long, successful career as a Hollywood leading man and movie star. Then, in 2006, he took the role of NBC executive Jack Donaghy. Baldwin earned two Emmys and three Golden Globes playing Liz Lemon's (Tina Fey) foil and work husband.

    The sitcom featured an unprecedented.The show used nine to 11 jokes per minute.Baldwin delivered about double of both.South Park.andFamily Guy.Other characters on the series got sight gags. Baldwin's smooth delivery and perfect comic timing created one of television's wittiest deadpan characters.30 Rock.Baldwin kept up with the pace; he made it look easy.

Comments (0)

Join the conversation

Sign in to share your take and reply to others.

First take? Share what stood out to you.

More like this