Killers often use controlled environments like homes or properties to commit crimes. For some, a basement is a convenient place to dispose of a body without being discovered. But for methodical offenders, basements can serve as makeshift prisons for victims. John Wayne Gacy and Gary Heidnik used their homes to commit and conceal murders. The Toy Box Killer owned a remote property where he imprisoned women undetected. From dirty New York tenement rooms to carefully constructed Austrian chambers, these basements show how criminals evaded police detection. Crimes on this list date back to the late 19th century, when H.H. Holmes built a murder castle, and continue up to 2016.
About this list
- 1

H.H. Holmes, or Dr. Henry Howard Holmes, killed up to 200 people between 1891 and 1894.Holmes confessed to 27 murders.Illinois hung the doctor in 1896 for these murders. The doctor used his Chicago castle to trap, torment with psychology, and kill.
Holmes hired and fired builders for nearly a decade to add parts to his "murder castle".He built his murder castle.The castle included pipes to pump gas into bedrooms, a room designed to suffocate people, and a basement for murder and experimentation.It had more.H.H. Holmes's 'Murder Castle' appears in the list 'Creepy Murder Rooms From Killers'.
0 - 2

Leonard Lake, along with Charles Ng, murdered men, women, and children during the mid-1980s.The duo confined female victims in a chamber Lake built in a remote California cabin. They abducted victims, often families, and used torture before killing them.. Lake committed suicide before police could arrest him. California eventually caught Ng and charged him with 11 murders.
Lake committed suicide before police could arrest him. California eventually caught Ng and charged him with.He committed 11 murders.The police arrested him in 1999 after a victim escaped.
0 - 3

David Parker Ray, also known as The Toy Box Killer, built a $100,000 torture chamber in New Mexico near his home in Elephant Butte. The steel-lined trailer is called the “Josef Fritzl abducted and confined his 18-year-old daughter, Elisabeth, in a basement.Police arrested him in 1999 after one victim escaped.
The FBI thinks Ray and his partners killed many women. Courts convicted him of kidnap and rape in 2001, sentencing him to224 years.Reportedly, Weston, with helpers, kept men and women confined for about 10 years.
0 - 4

Josef Fritzl took and locked up his 18-year-old daughter, Elisabeth, in aJohn Wayne Gacy is a famous serial killer in American history. Gacy sexually assaulted and killed dozens of men and boys in Illinois from 1972 to 1978. Chicago police found 28 of Gacy’s 33 victims in the crawlspace beneath his house.he built under his Austrian home. Fritzl told his wife and police. Elisabeth ran, but Fritzl kept her in the5-room basementfor 24 years.
Fritzl allegedly sexually assaulted his daughter daily. She mothered seven children. One child died when Fritzl would not take the infant to the hospital. In 2008, he let the oldest, who was very sick, leave, alerting authorities to negligence. Austrian courtsfound him guilty of murderin 2009.
0 - 5
In 2011, Philadelphia police found Linda Ann Weston kept mentally disabled people in her apartment basement. She forced them into sex work and stole their social security benefits. Investigators found one captive chained to the building's boiler early in the investigation.
Weston reportedly confined men and women for about10 years.Weston eventually admitted guilt to196 counts, including kidnapping, sex trafficking, and fraud. She got a life sentence for her crimes.
0 - 6

John Wayne Gacy is a famous serial killer in American history. Gacy sexually assaulted and killed many men and boys in Illinois from 1972 to 1978. Chicago police found 28 of Gacy’s 33 victims in thecrawlspacebeneath his house.
In 1980, courts convicted Gacy and gave him the death penalty. The “Killer Clown” got thelethal injectionin 1994.
0 - 7

In 1988, the state of Pennsylvania found Gary Heidnik guilty.Gary HeidnikHeidnik committed two murders. Heidnik abducted six African American women, most with known mental disabilities, and held them captive in his Philadelphia basement. Heidnik sexually assaulted andHeidnik tortured his victims.Two victims died from this.
Heidnik dug a pit in his basement floor. He filled it with water and electrocuted the women. Heidnik received thelethal injection.Heidnik got the lethal injection in 1999. This was the last execution in Pennsylvania.
0 - 8

In 2010, Chicago police charged Jeffrey Mundt and Joseph Banis with murder. The duo used GBH to drug 37-year-old James Carroll, an alleged lover, then killed him and buried him in a plastic tub in a Louisville basement. The “couplereportedly smashed Carroll’s body with a sledgehammer after death.
Mundt testified his boyfriend, Banis, cut Carroll’s throat. Banis testified against Mundt to avoid a death sentence. Banis got a life sentence for murder; Mundt's conviction only included robbery and tampering with evidence.
0 - 9
In 2014, Catrina McGhaw found her St. Louis rental above abasement.This basement was the site of Maury Travis’s alleged torture chamber. Police charged Travis with abducting, confining, and murderingtwo prostitutes.Travis allegedly killed about 17 women, but Travis killed himself in police custody in 2002. Courts could not try him for the suspected crimes.
McGhaw’s landlord, Travis's mother, would not let McGhawbreak the lease.but the housing authority stepped in.
0 - 10
In 2016, 39-year-old Andrea Caruth’s boyfriend reported her missing. Police found Andrea’s body in her father's Bronx apartment basement. Investigators found the bodyin a hole.William Caruth dug into the closet. Caruth reportedly beat Andrea with a hammer and strangled her dead.
Police said Caruth killed his pregnant daughter after a fight over finances. Baychester courts convicted Caruth of manslaughter and sentenced him to25 years in prison.William Caruth's Basement Closet is in prison.
0 - 11

The courts convicted Peter Tobin in 2007 for killing 23-year-old Angelika Kluk. Before his 2006 arrest, Tobin served a 10-year sentence for rape. Authorities searched his Margate home and found the remains of two women—Vicky Hamilton, 15, and Dinah McNicol, 18—who had been missingsince 1991..
The Peter Tobin case involves DNA evidence.DNA evidence.left on Kluk’s body, recovered from a Glasgow Church, led to finding more victims in Tobin’s garden. Police alsoPeter Tobin excavated the basements.of Tobin’s former properties searching for more possible victims.
0 - 12

Cleveland, OH police recovered the remains of 11 women from the basement of the duplex where Anthony Sowell allegedly lured his victims with the promise of free drugs and alcohol before strangling them to death. According toNews OneSowell's neighbors complained about a rotting smell for months; authorities then apprehended him.
In 2011, courts convicted Sowell on 11 murder counts. They sentenced him to death. Sowell’sRepeated appeals have postponed the execution date.Repeated appeals have postponed the execution date.
0 - 13
In 2016, Salvatore Perrone faced trial for killing three Middle Eastern shopkeepers near New York. Perrone used a sawed-off .22 rifle to execute the men. An NYPD detective saw Perrone's basement as looking like agarage sale.Perrone reportedly used his basement to practice shooting and plan the murders of the Brooklyn shopkeepers.
New York courts convicted Perrone and sentenced him to75 years in prison.75 years in prison.
0 - 14

In April 2016, West Virginia police arrested Woody Alfred Wood Jr. after his sister-in-law reported Wood’s wife, Rebecca, missing. Law enforcement found Rebecca’s dismembered bodyin the basement.He reportedly shot his wife, dismembered her body, and buried trash bags full of the remains.
Wood pled guilty to second-degree murder and got a 40-year prison sentence.
0
More like this

Most Notorious Serial Killers
Meet the world's most infamous serial killers, including photos, bios, and more. From America to abroad, these notorious serial murderers, both living and dead, are ordered by their level of infamy.

America's Most Famous Serial Killers
America's most famous serial killers are listed here, though infamous may be a better fit. Their murderous exploits have captured the nation's attention, and continue to do so.

Most Prolific American Serial Killers
The United States has been home to some of humanity's worst serial killers. American serial killers like these have the highest number of victims in history, making them the scariest human beings on the planet. Many other prolific serial killers exist.

Famous American Serial Killers
The US is home to a disproportionate number of serial killers. Born or operating in the US, these notorious individuals outnumber their counterparts in other countries on a per capita basis - possibly due to more comprehensive law enforcement records. This list highlights notable US serial killers.

Comments (0)
Join the conversation
Sign in to share your take and reply to others.
First take? Share what stood out to you.