Sony and Marvel Studios are parting ways, which may lead to another Spider-Man reboot. Who should play Peter Parker next? Tom Holland, Tobey Maguire, and Andrew Garfield have all donned the Spidey suit. Now, a new crop of actors could take on the role. When The Amazing Spider-Man reboot started, Sam Raimi's Spider-Man trilogy was barely five years old - a fourth film was even in pre-production with Anne Hathaway as Black Cat. A new reboot wouldn't be out of character for Sony. There are three possible paths for a new Spider-Man franchise: a complete reboot with a very young Spider-Man, a reboot that mentions the character without retelling the origin story, or an older, more seasoned Spider-Man. We'll focus on the second and third options, but these young actors could also fit a reboot. All of these actors would make great Spider-Men, regardless of whether Marvel and Sony reach an agreement. Vote for your favorites and hope Sony listens.
About this list
- 1

The Divergent star made a big impression. He is attractive, young, charming, talented, has stunt experience, and will bring in many female viewers.DivergentTheo James made a big impression on many people. He is attractive, young, charming, talented, has stunt experience, and will bring in many female viewers.
489 - 2

Andrew Garfield plays a great Peter Parker and Spider-Man. He is not the franchise's problem. He has the look, the humor, and serious acting skills. Keep Garfield for the Spidey films; lose the writers, and maybe Marc Webb too.
140 - 3

Dylan is the right age to play Peter Parker during his high school years. He surprised audiences inMazerunner, and he has a fan following fromTeen Wolf. He is perfect for the role.
79 - 4

The ShamelessThe star suffered a franchise defeat once whenDragonball Zwas... whateverDragonball ZHe deserves a second chance. He is talented, funny, charismatic, and he looks like someone drew an anime-style Peter Parker into the real world.
-108 - 5

Nat screams Peter Parker! If you do not see him as a science nerd or freelance photographer, something is wrong with you.
-109 - 6

The ShamelessThe star has not gotten the attention he deserves. He is snarky but endearing, intelligent, and incredibly talented. He deserves a franchise and would make a great Peter Parker.
-125 - 7

For the adorable, bookworm, funny guy, look no further than Justin Long. You can almost hear his voice quipping from behind that Spidey mask now.
-125 - 8

This guy can act. He can act. We want a thespian of his grandeur to join a Spider-Man franchise. He is young, funny, talented, a little nerdy, and perfect for Peter Parker.
-127 - 9

People love to make this guy a superhero. He was an original property hero when he led the cast ofThe Tomorrow People, and he appeared as Firestorm inThe Flash.Personally, we think he is more of a Spider-Man!
-128 - 10

Freddie would capture Peter's nerdy side, which Andrew Garfield's portrayal lacked (he was just an outsider). He has the talent and resume to bring quality to the role. Cast him!
-131 - 11

We are kidding, but we could not resist running this amazing photo we found putting this list together. J.K. for Spider-Man?! Vote him up if you think so.
-133 - 12

Wouldn't it be crazy if Harry Osborn's little brother was the new Peter Parker? He has the sense of humor, the look, the build, and the following. We think he would bring something different and special to the beloved character.
-135 - 13

Back when Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 2 was starting up, Tobey Maguire was still recovering from a back injury sustained while filmingSeabiscuit. Theyreportedlywere days away from having to recast him with Gyllenhaal. Since then, Jake Gyllenhaal has proven himself an insanely talented actor.
He is on a recent run of dark, character-driven dramas... what better way to bring in a new franchise than by skipping plot lines we have already seen?
-135 - 14

Ever since Across the UniverseJim Sturgess has been lobbing for Spider-Man to play. Then21Jim Sturgess is smart, quick-witted, and cool. He fits perfectly as an older, experienced Webslinger.
-144 - 15

Zac Efron is a controversial pick. He has proven himself since High School Musical.High School MusicalPeople do not credit Zac Efron for High School Musical. A big franchise with action/comedy exposure would help. He has the charm, look, physique, and draws people to the seats.
-145 - 16

Josh Hutcherson was very close to getting the Pete/Spidey role in The Amazing Spider-Man.The Amazing Spider-ManJosh Hutcherson was close when Marc Webb started the new franchise. You can find his stunt audition tape readily online.readily availableJosh Hutcherson shows passion for the character, has the look, and is the right age for a younger Peter Parker. He fits well.The Hunger GamesAfter Hunger Games ended, why not make another huge franchise?
-154 - 17

Logan Lerman has done spectacular work in every role. He has over a decade of experience but is young enough to play Parker in the origin story. With Percy Jackson,Percy Jackson, The Perks of Being a Wallflower,andFury,Logan Lerman has quite the talent.the following.
-157 - 18

We suggest Harry Potter play Spider-Man. For his career, it is another huge character with a wide fan base that could change the image of Harry Potter.
From a Spidey fan point of view, he is young, versatile, talented, and has the look and humor for the role. From a business angle, he sells many tickets, even The Woman in Blackgot a sequel!
He is clearly a fan; look how he dressed at the 2014 San Diego Comic Con.
-159 - 19

Forget Joseph Gordon-Levitt playing Robin. An older Spider-Man is the role he belongs in. Nerdy yet attractive, smarmy but charming, he shows range like Pete versus Spider-Man. He would ace both sides of the superhero!
-160 - 20

The TV star who has carried Supernaturalfor a decadeis long overdue for a superhero franchise. His boyish looks, sarcastic charm, and dedicated fans make him the perfect person for the Parker/Spidey role.
-166
More like this

The Best Male Actors Working Today
Over 148K fans voted on 290+ people in Best (Male) Actors Working Today, with Morgan Freeman, Leonardo DiCaprio, and Denzel Washington currently in the top 3.

The Hottest Men Of 2021, Ranked
The hottest men of 2021 have it all - pretty faces and perfect physiques. These male celebrities top the list.

Hottest Men 2020, Ranked
Check out the hottest men of 2021! Each year brings new faces, but 2020's crop of sexy men still sizzles. These male celebrities have got it going on. Some call them the sexiest men of 2020, and for good reason. Attraction comes in many forms.

Hottest Male Celebrities & Actors 2026, Ranked
Over 26,000 fans voted on 150+ people for Hottest Male Celebrities & Actors Of 2026, Ranked. The top 3 are Chris Hemsworth, Henry Cavill, and Michael B. Jordan.

Comments (0)
Join the conversation
Sign in to share your take and reply to others.
First take? Share what stood out to you.