Skip to main content

Candyman Sequels Fail To Match Original

By Every Day Story12 items
Share

About this list

For '90s horror fans, the real terror wasn't Freddy Krueger or Jason Voorhees - it was saying 'Candyman' five times in a bathroom mirror. Clive Barker's short story inspired a gothic-style horror film that explored urban legends and Black culture in Chicago's urban sprawl. The film's success led to two '90s sequels, each less successful than the last, both financially and in conveying important messages. The sequels kept the concept of Candyman appearing after his name was said into a mirror, but the explanation became increasingly convoluted. The third film, sent straight to DVD, is still worth watching - like Freddy vs. Jason - for its so-bad-it's-good appeal. Before watching the new Candyman, revisit the character's origins and downfall.

Crowd-ranked
Anything
updating live12 items
  • 1
    The First 'Candyman' Is A Work Of Art That Was Ahead Of Its Time

    The First 'Candyman' Is A Work Of Art That Was Ahead Of Its Time is based on Clive Barker’s short story.The Forbidden, Candymanis aa uniquely American horror storyIt explores race, folklore, and belief in a genuinely creepy movie.CandymanA young PhD student, played by Virginia Madsen, investigates slayings attributed to the "Candyman," a specter with a hook for a hand haunting Chicago's Cabrini-Green area.

    While investigating these ruthless acts, she finds the legend true. She also sees a story built on America's deep history of racism. Anthony B. Richmond's stunning cinematography and a score by Philip Glass augment the story.Philip Glass scored itThe film avoids screeching jump scare sounds found in lesser movies. Instead, it builds a haunting atmosphere.

    Tony Todd's leading menace makes the film effective. He does not chase or chop like Jason or Michael, nor does he quip like Freddy. Instead, he asks Madsen's character to become his victim, to merge with his story. In under 20 minutes, Todd creates a horror movie monster.a horror movie monsterThis monster terrifies more people than the slashers he shared the video store with.

    Anything
  • 2
    The Second Film Made The Mistake Of Attempting To Explain Candyman's Origins

    Inthe initialCandyman, the character’s origins remain vague. He is believed to be the angry rebirth of a Black painter from the late 19th or early 20th century whose father was a slave. After loving and impregnating a white woman, he was hanged and his painting hand removed. As the Candyman legend grew, he returned with a hook instead of a paintbrush.

    Audiences know this about Candyman in the first film. They also know that if someone says his name five times in a mirror, curtains close.Candyman: Farewell to the Flesh, the sequel toCandyman, tried to add to the villain’s story withtoo many specifics.

    The story moved from Chicago to New Orleans. There, Candyman became Daniel Robitaille, a slave from long ago. He shows his bee-stung face in a hand mirror. As he fades, his soul moves into the mirror, and the mob chants “Candyman” repeatedly.

    Urban legends and folklore do not need a straight story. Their lack of detail makes them unsettling. This lack of detail helps solidify the original film's mysterious nature.

    Anything
  • 3
    The Original Film Was Meant To Give The Black Community Their Own 'Dracula'

    Before the Candyman became another slasher in video stores, he was presented as the first gothic horror character for the Black community. At a retrospective of the first film, Virginia Madsen explained the story's idea and how she backed out.when the sequel started changing the story:the sequel began to change the narrative:

    Bernie [Rose] wanted to make Candyman an African American Dracula, which appealed to the African American community because they finally had their own Dracula. Candyman was a poet and smart; he was not a monster, more like a classical figure.

    Separately,Rose explained, "The idea always was that he was a romantic figure. Again, romantic in the Edgar Allen Poe sense."

    Anything
  • 4
    'Farewell to the Flesh' Traded Social Commentary For Typical Slasher Fare And Cheap Jump Scares

    Much of the tension in the initialCandymanrelies on Madsen’s character visiting the projects and questioning her motives as a white woman. Does she want to help, or does she just use other people's suffering to get her PhD? This vanishes inFarewell to the Flesh.

    Though the two films share a similar plot—a blonde white woman helps the inner-city population investigate murders—the sequel fails to use the horror of the first film. Instead of using the restraint of the original, it uses jump scares.

    Thefalse scaresinFarewell to the Fleshunderplay moments when Candyman actually appears. His appearances use quick scares instead of the atmospheric moments from the original movie.

    Anything
  • 5
    Some Critics Found ‘Farewell To The Flesh’ Inadvertently Racist

    Many critics ofFarewell to the Fleshnoted the film lacked the cultural understanding and sensitivity of its predecessor. Some found the sequel and its New Orleans settinginadvertently racist. The first film shows Madsen’s character struggling to enter a Black community. The sequel’s main character enters the community right away and receives thanks from many people. It follows many of the same beats as the now-criticizedwhite savior trope.

    Few people working onFarewell to the Fleshentered production with bad intentions, but how the Black community is treated in the film misses the mark.

    Anything
  • 6
    ‘Farewell to the Flesh’ Is Narrated By A DJ With An Exaggerated Creole Accent

    Viewers will either love or hate something aboutFarewell to the FleshFarewell to the Flesh is its narration byradio DJ for 96.2 New Orleans, Kingfish. Like theDJ fromThe Warriors, the monologues by Kingfish add narrative force to the scenes. Kingfish's deep Nawlins drawl makes his monologues hard to take seriously, though.

    As the film's voice, Kingfish shows viewers what city residents think. These moments could be interesting, but they suffer because Kingfish tells Candyman to “relax” and “enjoy a big bowl of gumbo.”

    Anything
  • 7
    The Third Film, 'Day of the Dead,' Further Complicates Candyman's Backstory

    WhileFarewell to the Fleshunnecessarily adds to Candyman’s history. Some viewers might like the character having a clear reason for his actions and an explanation for how he moves through reflective surfaces. Not every horror fan wants an indirect backstory for the villain.

    That said,Candyman: Day of the Dead piles on the expositionCandyman pops out of mirrors to end lives. He now tries to woo his great-great-granddaughter, not seeking revenge. This makes the character look strange, not just a slasher.

    Anything
  • 8
    The Third Film Blends In Elements Of Latinx Folklore And Tradition With Confusing Results

    The third film leaves the specific cultural storytelling of the first two movies entirely.The film features Day of the Dead.The film mixes Candyman’s backstory with Latinx folklore.The film blends Latinx folklore.The film tries to feel different from the previous two, but it confuses the character’s story.

    Latinx history offers no direct link to Candyman's origin. It acts as an excuse to film in Los Angeles instead of Chicago or New Orleans.

    Anything
  • 9
    The Third Film Stars Donna D'Errico Of 'Baywatch' Fame

    Virginia Madsen shows great dramatic power. She brings a dynamic nature to the gothic horror.The film features Candyman.The third film makes everything feel more important. Donna D'Errico of Baywatch stars, which heightens the movie's impact.The film stars Donna D'Errico of Baywatch fame.The film also includes.The film includes Battlebots.D’Errico is an actor, but she lacks Madsen's dramatic acting skill.

    D’Errico struggles to sell the horror. The movie feels like an episode of Baywatch Nights.The film includes Baywatch Nights.Everyone D'Errico meets overacts or underacts. Each person seems given a different acting direction.

    Anything
  • 10
    The Third Installment Went Straight To Video

    The first two films got theatrical releases. The third installment went straight to DVD.The third installment went straight to DVD.The sets are blank. Effects look uninspired. The most interesting scene happens on Los Angeles streets.

    Turi Meyer wrote and directed the film. Meyer wrote Leprechaun 2.The third installment went straight to video.The third installment went straight to video.The third installment went straight to video.These sequels misunderstand the films that came before them.The film features Day of the Dead.Day of the Dead reflects the tone of most straight-to-DVD films. Digital format makes visuals flat. The film shows more undress than previous movies.

    Anything
  • 11
    The Third Film Has One Great Scare

    A few moments in the third film show everyone on set trying to make something interesting. Police detain Donna D’Errico’s character. Officers handcuff her and put her in a squad car. One officer says “Candyman” five times into the rearview mirror. This was a bad idea.

    He runs through Candy’s hook hand and dies in the driver's seat. D’Errico climbs over his lap for a long scene to exit the car. The audience knows what happens, but the cop’s sudden shout terrifies her.

    Anything
  • 12
    There’s A Cult Of Creepy Goths Who Worship The Candyman In The Third Film

    The third installment features a big twist: a cult of goths tries to make Donna D’Errico’s character believe the Candyman is real so they can bring him into the real world. The reason they call upon the angry, hook-handed specter with a drive for gruesome killings is unclear, but it is surprising.

    Members of the cult wear much black and fishnet and have many piercings, similar to the typical '90s movie goth look.

    2021's film was lucky.CandymanThe film largely ignored the two sequels and instead continued the story of the first film.

    Anything

Comments (0)

Join the conversation

Sign in to share your take and reply to others.

First take? Share what stood out to you.

More like this